Daily Economic Update: October 22, 2024

Stocks fell and yields rose.  All of the worries were on display in financial media yesterday.  Stocks, well Goldman says you won't make money in stocks.  Bonds, well deficits.  Cash, well inflation.  Even crypto and gold didn't work for the day.  Investing is hard. 

We ended the day with the 2Y back up over 4 at 4.04% and the 10Y at 4.20%. 

There's an idea of market cycles and reversions to the mean, ‘trees don’t grow to the sky’.  Contrasting to that is the idea that the we're in a new age and there are some companies that have learned to scale at levels not seen before in history, a new Industrial Revolution, an exponential age with increasing returns to scale. 

In the "new" economic system the thinking is summed up in a 2019 in an essay called "Graham or Growth" by investor James Anderson:

"They have endured for decades even at massive scale. I don’t see this as a contention but as an observation. Ironically they’ve altered the patterns of stock market return sufficiently that the very utility of the ‘mean’ has been undermined. The mean is now so far above the median stock that our entire notion of the distribution of returns has to be reviewed. The first chance to reassess came with Microsoft over 30 years ago. The investment community has been slow indeed. We can react to economic data or quarterly earnings in seconds but adjusting our world view has proven far harder.

Separately, one can wonder what if the recent higher interest rate environment somewhat counterintuitively helped repair balance sheets, stopped the proliferation of "zombie" firms, and allowed for the reallocation of capital to more productive uses, thus helping fuel growth (an idea once posited by Claudio Borio).  

Further, despite all the deficits, what if we're poised for more growth than we think.  After all, in the fiscal theory of the price level: "I emphasize: fiscal theory says you get inflation if debt exceeds faith in a country’s long run ability and will to repay. There is no hard and fast debt/GDP limit. Argentina has debt crises at 40% debt to GDP. Japan lasted a decade at over 200%."  This John Cochrane substack post on debt sustainability is worth a read (in the last two paragraphs that's about as optimistic as Cochrane seems to get).

It’s all a lot to think about with political and geopolitcal risk abounding, so it’s important to have intellectual humility.

Jason Zweig recently described how Ben Graham’s concept of margin of safety was also meant to apply at the individual level, to yourself as an investor. In the personal context he posited:  "Do I know what I think I know? How do I know what I think I know?  What evidence is there that I might be wrong?... Why do I know something about this asset that other investors haven't figured out? Why exactly would I be right when all of them are wrong?  

Somewhat related to humility, Morgan Housel's latest post "A Message From the Past (Thoughts on Nostalgia) does a nice job of adding some perspective around the current environment.  In it:

"Are we now forgetting that at virtually every moment of the last 15 years, smart people argued that the market was overvalued, recession was near, hyperinflation was around the corner, the country was bankrupt, the numbers were manipulated, the dollar was worthless, on and on?

I think we forget these things because we now know how the story ends: the stock market went up a lot. If you held on tight, none of those past events mattered. So it’s easy to discount – even ignore – how they felt at the time. You think back and say, “That was so easy, money was free, the market went straight up.” Even if few people actually felt that way during the last 15 years.

So much of what matters in investing – this is true for a lot of things in life – is how you manage the psychology of uncertainty. The problem with looking back with hindsight is that nothing is uncertain. You think no one had anything to worry about, because most of what they were worrying about eventually came to pass.

“You should have been happy and calm, given where things ended up,” you say to your past self. But your past self had no idea where things would end up. Uncertainty dictates nearly everything in the current moment, but looking back we pretend it never existed.

Concluding with "The past wasn’t as good as you remember. The present isn’t as bad as you think. The future will be better than you anticipate."

And that's about as much optimism as you're going to get from me.

XTOD: The World Series between the Dodgers and Yankees is sold out and there are no tickets under $1,000 on the secondary market. 

XTOD: If there is not radical reduction of government expenditures, then, just like an individual who has taken on too much debt, America will become de facto bankrupt.  The interest on the debt is trending to rapidly absorb all tax revenue, leaving nothing for critical needs.

XTOD: The speculative public is incorrigible. In financial terms it cannot count beyond 3. It will buy anything, at any price, if there seems to be some “action” in progress. It will fall for any company identified with “franchising,” computers, electronics, science, technology, or what have you, when the particular fashion is raging. --Benjamin Graham

XTOD: Understand: the greatest generals, the most creative strategists, stand out not because they have more knowledge but because they are able, when necessary, to drop their preconceived notions and focus intensely on the present moment. That is how creativity is sparked and opportunities are seized. Knowledge, experience, and theory have limitations: no amount of thinking in advance can prepare you for the chaos of life, for the infinite possibilities of the moment. The great philosopher of war Carl von Clausewitz called this “friction”: the difference between our plans and what actually happens. Since friction is inevitable, our minds have to be capable of keeping up with change and adapting to the unexpected. The better we can adapt our thoughts to changing circumstances, the more realistic our responses to them will be. The more we lose ourselves in predigested theories and past experiences, the more inappropriate and delusional our response.

https://x.com/ArashMarkazi/status/1848377570976465383

https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1848467092116254998

https://x.com/jasonzweigwsj/status/1847981234191814843

https://x.com/RobertGreene/status/1848469335095873977